Wholetally vs Google Analytics 4

Every claim about Google Analytics 4 links to the page that says it. We read them in November 2026.

Wholetally and Google Analytics 4
Question Wholetally Google Analytics 4
Cookies on your visitors’ devices None. No cookies, no localStorage or sessionStorage. Yes Yes: _ga and _ga_<id>, 2 years by default. Analytics Help: Google Analytics cookie usage on websites
How a unique visitor is counted By referrer: a visit from another site or with no referrer is unique. An optional daily-rotating hash mode is off by default. A client ID stored in the _ga cookie. Analytics Help: Google Analytics cookie usage on websites
Visitors who decline consent The script needs no cookies or device storage. Whether you need a banner depends on your country and setup: check with your legal advisor. Partly Basic consent mode sends nothing. Advanced mode sends cookieless pings; modelling needs 1,000+ events a day for 7 days. Google Tag Platform: Consent mode overview Analytics Help: Behavioral modeling for consent mode
Serve the script from your own domain Yes: guides for Cloudflare Workers, Vercel, Next.js and Nginx. Yes Yes, with a server-side Tag Manager container on your domain. Server-side Tag Manager: custom domain
Counts page loads with no JavaScript Yes: the edge collector counts every HTML response, deduplicated against script hits. No No. The Measurement Protocol adds to the tag, it doesn’t replace it. Measurement Protocol (Google Analytics 4)
AI crawler report Yes: per crawler, per page, at the edge. Kept out of visitor numbers. No No. Known bots are excluded and you can’t see how many. Analytics Help: Known bot-traffic exclusion
AI assistants as a referral channel Yes, including utm_source=chatgpt.com. Yes Yes: an AI Assistant channel. Analytics Help: Default channel group
Revenue by source Yes: Stripe webhooks (incl. iDEAL), refunds subtract. Test-mode events only for now: live-mode payments are not processed yet. Yes Yes: purchase events with value and currency. GA4: Measure ecommerce
MCP server for AI agents Yes: built in, read-only tools plus add_site. Yes Yes: a read-only MCP server on Google Analytics’ GitHub. googleanalytics/google-analytics-mcp on GitHub
Where the data is EU: the analytics database is in Cloudflare’s EU jurisdiction. Requests are handled at the nearest Cloudflare location, which can be outside the EEA. EU traffic is collected on EU servers, then sent on to Google’s data centres for processing. Analytics Help: EU-focused data and privacy
Open source The script, under MIT. The MCP server is open source; GA4 itself is not. googleanalytics/google-analytics-mcp on GitHub

Where Google Analytics 4 is a good fit

The default for most sites, free to start and very deep.

See all four side by side

Count the visitors you’ve been missing.

30-day free trial, no card needed. Create an account with your email and add your first site.

Start 30-day trial