Looking for a Simple Analytics alternative? What to check first

Simple Analytics is a solid Dutch cookieless tool. Before you switch, check AI crawlers, AI referrals, revenue per source, funnels, MCP and price.

Wholetally team Blog

Short answer

Simple Analytics is a good cookieless tool, so look for an alternative only if it misses something you need every week. The usual reasons are a per-crawler report of AI bots such as GPTBot, AI assistants as their own traffic channel, revenue per traffic source from Stripe, or pricing that fits many sites. Plausible and Fathom are the closest like-for-like options. If AI traffic and revenue are the gap, pick a tool built for those reports, and test it next to Simple Analytics for 30 days before you move.

What does Simple Analytics already do well?

Start here, because a fair comparison begins with what you would give up. Based on its own pages, checked on 17 November 2026:

  • No cookies and EU storage. It sets no cookies, and its pricing page says website data is stored in the EU, with its primary infrastructure in the Netherlands.
  • A one-page dashboard. Referrers, pages, countries, UTM codes and devices, with filters you can combine. Since script version 12 it also splits search traffic into paid and organic.
  • Goals, funnels and email reports. Its features page lists events, goals, multi-step funnels and weekly or monthly email reports.
  • An MCP server. Its docs describe connecting Claude, ChatGPT, Claude Code or Codex, on every plan including Free.
  • A free plan. For hobby sites, with one month of history and a badge. Paid self-serve plans are priced by pageviews, with a 14-day trial.

If that list covers your questions, you probably do not need an alternative. If it does not, the sections below show where the differences are.

Why do people look for a Simple Analytics alternative?

In conversations with agencies, SaaS founders and webshops, four reasons come up.

  1. AI crawlers. Simple Analytics hides bot visits from the dashboard; you can download them, but there is no report per crawler and per page. That is a reasonable choice for a visitor dashboard, and a gap if you work on AI search visibility.
  2. AI assistants as a channel. A visit from ChatGPT shows up as a referrer such as chatgpt.com when the browser sends one, or through utm_source. We did not find a separate AI assistant channel in its docs.
  3. Revenue per source. Its features page lists events and goals, but we found no payment-provider integration. If you sell online, “visitors from LinkedIn” matters less than “euros from LinkedIn”.
  4. Price at your traffic and site count. Pricing by pageviews and by extra user works well for one site. Agencies should price the total for all client sites and team members.

Which tools are closest to Simple Analytics?

If you like how Simple Analytics works and only want a second opinion on price or interface, the closest options are other cookieless dashboards. Details below come from each vendor’s pages as summarised in our comparison; check them again before you buy.

  • Plausible. Open source under AGPLv3, hosted or self-hosted, with visitor data kept in the EU. It added an AI Assistants channel in June 2026, and revenue goals are on its Business plan. A good pick if open source matters to you.
  • Fathom. A polished hosted dashboard. EU visitors’ personal data is processed in the EU, while anonymised analytics are stored in the US. It added an AI tab in Referrers in October 2026, and it blocks AI scrapers as bots rather than reporting them per crawler.
  • GA4. Not a like-for-like swap: it uses cookies, so in most EU countries it runs behind a consent banner. Keep it only if you depend on Google Ads audiences and conversion import. Our post on Google Analytics alternatives for EU sites covers that trade-off.

All three show people. None of them gives you a per-crawler, per-page view of AI bots from a browser script, because no browser script can see crawlers that skip JavaScript.

What should you check before you switch?

Every privacy-friendly tool looks alike on a feature grid. These questions separate them. Our comparison table goes row by row, with a source behind every cell.

  1. How is a unique visitor counted? Simple Analytics counts unique pageviews by referrer: a visit from another site or with no referrer is unique. Plausible and Fathom hash the IP address and user agent with a daily salt. Wholetally also counts by referrer by default, with an optional daily-rotating hash mode that is off by default. The method changes your numbers, so expect totals to differ.
  2. Does it store anything on the device? No cookies and no local storage is the starting point. Two cookieless tools should land in the same place here.
  3. Can you count visitors without JavaScript? Ad blockers and script failures leave holes. Simple Analytics offers a noscript pixel, a proxy guide and a server-side events API. An edge collector that counts every HTML response goes one step further.
  4. Does it report AI crawlers and AI referrals separately? They are two different things: bots reading your pages, and people clicking through from an assistant.
  5. Does it connect payments to the visit? And does it do that without a visitor ID or fingerprint?
  6. What can an AI agent do with your data? Read-only questions, or also changes to settings and goals? Who approves those?
  7. Where does data go when you use AI features? Simple Analytics asks before its in-app AI chat sends data to OpenAI. Ask the same question of any tool you test.

Why do AI crawlers need different data than visitors?

AI crawlers such as GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot fetch your HTML and leave. They do not run JavaScript, so no browser script ever sees them, from any vendor. OpenAI’s crawler documentation lists separate agents for training (GPTBot), for search (OAI-SearchBot) and for fetches a user asks for (ChatGPT-User), and each one is a different signal for your site.

To see which pages they read, you need data from the server, the CDN or the edge. That is what our AI report is for: the edge collector recognises crawlers by user agent, keeps them out of your visitor numbers and shows them per bot, per purpose and per page. For the details, read how to track GPTBot and other AI crawlers.

Be realistic about limits. An assistant can quote your page without anyone clicking, and that leaves no trace in any analytics tool. Crawler requests and referral visits are signals that your work is reaching AI search, not a full count of every AI interaction.

How do you see visitors from ChatGPT and other assistants?

In Simple Analytics, look at the Referrals list for domains such as chatgpt.com or perplexity.ai, and at utm_source values. That works, but you have to know which domains to look for and add them up yourself. A tool with an AI assistant channel groups them for you, including links that carry utm_source=chatgpt.com. Some assistant apps send no referrer at all, so part of that traffic still lands in direct, whatever tool you use. We explain the details in how to see ChatGPT traffic in your analytics.

Can a cookieless tool show revenue per traffic source?

Yes, if it ties the payment to the visit at checkout rather than following a person around. In Wholetally, revenue per source comes from Stripe webhooks, including iDEAL, and refunds subtract. You pass the visit’s source at checkout, so no visitor ID or fingerprint is needed. To be clear about where this stands: today it counts Stripe test-mode events, and live-mode payments are not processed yet.

Combine that with cookieless funnels and you can see which source brings people who reach checkout, not only people who land on the home page.

Is an MCP server still a reason to switch?

Less than it was. Simple Analytics now documents an MCP server on every plan, so “talk to your stats in Claude” is no longer rare. Compare the details instead: which data the agent can read, whether it can change anything, and how access is approved. Our MCP server lets Claude or ChatGPT connect by URL with OAuth sign-in, or Cursor and other agents with a token. On Wholetally it is part of the Growth plan and up.

Where does Wholetally fit, and where does it not?

This is our own product, so read this section with that in mind.

  • Fits: sites that care about AI search and want AI crawlers and AI referrals in one report, shops and SaaS that want revenue per source, and agencies that run many sites on one account. Built in the Netherlands, with the analytics database in Cloudflare’s EU jurisdiction.
  • Does not fit as well: a hobby site that only needs a free dashboard. Simple Analytics has a free plan; Wholetally starts with a 30-day trial and paid plans after that.
  • Plans matter. AI referrals are on every plan. The edge collector (needed for crawler data), funnels and MCP start on Growth; revenue per source and the REST API on Business. See Pricing for the amounts at your pageviews.

Want to check the fields we send before you install anything? The what we collect page lists every one.

How do you move from Simple Analytics without losing history?

  1. Export your history. Download the data you compare year over year with its export or API before you cancel.
  2. Run both for about 30 days. Add the new script next to the old one. Compare trends, top pages and top referrers, not exact totals.
  3. Recreate goals and keep your UTM habits. Use the same UTM tags so campaign reports line up across the switch.
  4. Add the edge collector if you want crawler data. On Cloudflare it is one Worker; on Next.js a few lines of middleware.
  5. Update your privacy policy. Name the new tool and its sub-processors. On the banner question, cookieless tools often mean no consent banner is needed for analytics, but that depends on your country and setup; check with your legal advisor. Our post on cookieless analytics and EU cookie banners goes into the detail.

What to do next

Write down the five questions you ask your analytics every week. If Simple Analytics answers all five, stay. If AI crawlers, AI referrals or revenue per source are on the list, run Wholetally next to it on your own site: start a 30-day trial, no card needed. Compare plans on Pricing, or read the full comparison first.

Wholetally is cookieless web analytics with an AI report, edge collection and revenue per source. Built in the Netherlands. This article is general information, not legal advice. Simple Analytics details come from its own pages, checked on 17 November 2026, and may change.

FAQ

What is a good alternative to Simple Analytics?
It depends on what you miss. Plausible and Fathom are close in spirit: cookieless, simple dashboards. If you want AI crawlers per bot and per page, AI assistants as their own channel, or Stripe revenue per traffic source, look at a tool built for those reports. If Simple Analytics already answers your weekly questions, staying is a fine choice.
Is Simple Analytics free?
It has a free plan for hobby sites, with one month of history and a badge, and paid self-serve plans priced by pageviews. New accounts get a 14-day trial of the paid features. Check its pricing page for current numbers, because they change with your traffic.
Does Simple Analytics show AI crawlers like GPTBot?
Its bot documentation says bot visits are hidden from the dashboard but can be downloaded. A browser script also never sees crawlers that do not run JavaScript. For a per-crawler, per-page report you need server, CDN or edge data.
Does Simple Analytics have an MCP server?
Yes. Its docs describe an MCP server for Claude, ChatGPT, Claude Code and Codex, on every plan including Free. So MCP alone is no longer a reason to switch; compare what the agent can read and change.
Will switching from Simple Analytics remove my need for a cookie banner?
Switching between two cookieless tools changes little here. A tool that stores nothing on the device often means no consent banner is needed for analytics, but that depends on your country and setup, and on every other script on your site. Check with your legal advisor.
How do I compare Simple Analytics with another tool fairly?
Run both on the same site for about 30 days and compare trends, top pages and top referrers, not exact totals. Tools count unique visitors and filter bots differently, so the numbers will not match one to one.

Sources

Count the visitors you’ve been missing.

30-day free trial, no card needed. Create an account with your email and add your first site.

Start 30-day trial